Review: Absolute Batman #25 (DC)

Updated: 1 minute ago
Batman and Joker finally fight, but does Snyder deliver the dust up fan were hoping for?


Writer: Scott Snyder
Artist: Nick Dragotta
Colorist: Frank Martin
Content Rating: T+
Spoilers Ahead
Absolute Batman has been on one of the hottest streaks of any comic book in modern times. For the past two years, the series has been a fixture at the top of the charts, and deservedly so. It's blend of bombastic writing and killer art make it a must-read on a monthly basis. And with the release of issue 25, fans are finally getting to see a confrontaition they've been waiting a long time for: Batman versus Joker. The only question was whether the conflict would live up to the hype.
The issue picks up right where #24 left off, with Batman rushing to take on Joker at his mansion. Except when Bruce comes bursting into the manor, he finds his quartet of friends waiting for him. It's the worst case scenario, where Joker has gotten to each of them and convinced them not only of his own innocence, but that Bruce is insane and needs help. Bruce's friend's genuinely want him to get better, not understanding that Joker is lying to them.

It was a bit much to buy into, honestly (especially Eddie), that not one of them could see through Grimm's machinations. It was nonetheless an interesting twist, with Bruce suffering from the choice he's made over the past (in-book) year of keeping all of his friends at arm's length. They would likely have a better sense of what's going on if he'd been open with them from the start, and perhaps Joker wouldn't have been able to get to them if he did. Instead, Bruce has been violent and seemingly irrational, making it that much easier to believe Joker's lies.
There will be some interesting consequences to come from this issue, too, as so many of the soon-to-be rogues are facing new status quos thanks to Grimm. Harvey is going to get his law license back; Oswald will have legitimate business operations; Eddie is going to encode "recursive intelligence" into a human brain; the only one we don't hear, but Bruce propbably has figured out, is Waylon, who is likely going to get a serum to cure his condition. The proverbial monkey's paw will eventually curl on all of these deals, surely, but for now the guys believe they've made the right choice and will do good with Grimm's help.

Of course, Bruce doesn't believe any of this and rejects their offer to get him checked in for psychiatric treatment. As he rushes across the grounds to evade the incoming police, Batman falls through a hole in the ground into a mysterious cave. Replete with an enormous penny and a dinosaur skeleton, Grimm's subversion of the classic Batman setup apparently extends to the character having his own Joker cave. And there, sitting and feeding on the swarm of babies clinging to his body (or whatever that is, it's been a couple years and readers still have no idea exactly what Joker is doing with his child victims) is Joker.
As Grimm disconnects himself from the babies, he rises from his chair and towers over Bruce, far larger than Batman and immensely imposing with his devil-like legs, horns, and a face full of sharp teeth. I'm still not totally sold on Joker being this demonic entity that he is in the Absolute Universe, but it's an undeniably striking design. The fight is brutal but ultimately brief. Not to pat myself on the back here, but I had zero expectation that this fight would go Bruce's way, nor did I think that it would be any sort of definitive end to these characters' rivalry. Still, it was satisfying seeing Bruce finally be able to take a swing at Joker, even if his physical attacks didn't do much to him.

Joker's berating of Batman during their fight was another interesting layer to analyze. While Joker has always been the Clown Prince of Crime, here he refers to Bruce as the latest in an apparently centures-long series of who he calls clowns, victims whose suffering is the only source of joy and, thus, laughter that Grimm knows. For his part, Bruce refuses to tell the "joke" that Joker is trying to beat out of him, remaining steadfast against the villain's vicious assault. And then... it's rescue time.
In case anyone hasn't noticed, Absolute Batman is a very progressive comic book series. Scott Snyder wears his politics on his sleeve, especially in interviews and on social media, but credit where credit is due, Absolute Batman has never suffered from the writer's political leanings. This issue, sadly, was the first time that I felt like Snyder was pushing the message too aggressively. First off, we see Barbara in her new identity of "The Bat" as she swoops in to rescue Batman from Joker. Noticeably, Joker refers to them as a duo, suggesting that Barbara will be Bruce's partner in this series and not any of the Robins.

This moniker of The Bat is clearly an effort to move away from gendered language; apparently a name like Batgirl or Batwoman is just too offensive and old fashioned for Snyder's tastes. Similarly, The Bat's costume is very intentionally un-feminine, but it's also really boring and lacks any of the iconic elements of either Batgirl or Batwoman, save for the cowl. In his efforts to be progressive, Snyder sucks all of the joy from one of the most vibrant characters in the DC pantheon.
A similar mistake is word that, at least according to him, Alfred will be going away for a while. His replacement seems to be Harley. Both of these things are undesirable. Harley is grating and obnoxious, working best in small doses; if Alfred is out of the picture, my assumption is that Snyder is positioning her to be his replacement. This would fit, again, within Snyder's progressive vision for the series: a predominantly female crew and the elimination of one more so-called problematic old white man from the series (he's already gotten rid of Gordon, after all). It's unfortunate because this version of Alfred is very engaging and there's still a lot of mystery surrounding him that I want to see resolved.

Artist Nick Dragotta delivers another home run with this issue. I do believe that other artists, like Eric Canete, are more than capable of working on this series, but Dragotta's distinctive style remains the bedrock upon which this book was built. His Batman's hulking from is so iconic and unique, as his twisted, eerie versions of Batman's friends/rogues. It made the underwhelming design of The Bat more disappointing, frankly, because I think Dragotta could do so much better, but I fear he's being limited by Snyder's vision on this one.
One last gripe/observation about this issue is Snyder has spent to much time telling and not showing the relationship between Bruce and his friends. Yes, there is the risk of wearing that part of the book too thin, but it sometimes feels like the quartet, with perhaps the exception of Waylon, is too briefly featured and not fleshed out enough. It's been 25 issues of brief asides with the guys and not enough in depth one-on-one time. What's more, Snyder very much wants the crew to not be outright villains. While I get that these characters are different from the originals, and that some of them are historically complicated/gray (Two-Face, for instance), I feel like this push for sympathetic enemies is more a tenet of progressivism than a result of story necessity.
So, a couple of big changes that don't land very well, but I'm willing to hold out judgment until I see how Snyder handles it all. After all, so far he's guided everyone on a rocking two-year journey with few notable missteps; maybe I'll feel differently after I see where this is all leading. I will point out, however, that this is the last issue of Absolute Batman until January of 2027. Absolute Batman: Ark M #1 was supposed to launch this month, but alas, it, too has slipped into January. We'll all have to wait a little longer to get our next look at Batman, not to mention the crazy cliffhanger this issue left us on. Overall, it was a solid issue that's definitely worth a read.







